Welfare Pros And Cons Essay On School

It's a challenge to define what 'welfare' means in the United States, but it's vital to understand exactly what it is before you approach the pros and cons. There are many benefits and drawbacks to welfare, and the topic continues to elicit strong emotions in Americans from every political persuasion.

What Constitutes Welfare?

Welfare can be broadly defined as a government program, funded by taxpayers, that provides financial aid to individuals or groups who cannot support themselves.

In the United States, welfare programs are administered by both the state and federal governments. They are means-tested programs, meaning that an individual must prove need before they are approved for benefits.

Examples of the wide variety of welfare programs include:

  • Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF)
  • Medicaid
  • Supplemental Security Income (SSI)
  • Supplemental Nutritional Assistance Program (SNAP)
  • Housing Assistance
  • Head Start
  • Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants and Children (WIC)

Looking at welfare statistics can help you better understand how the programs are being used. Welfare programs focus on those who are disabled or raising children. If you are not disabled and not raising children, it can be very difficult to qualify for and maintain welfare assistance.

Arguments in Favor of Welfare

Those in favor of welfare point to the many benefits the programs provide for the poor and their families.

High Need Among Americans

Advocates point to the many benefits of welfare programs. As of September 2016, over 67 million Americans received welfare assistance from the government, and over 70 million Americans qualified for Medicaid. Clearly, there are a lot of people in need, and welfare helps ensure that they can find help.

Helps Children

National Public Radio (NPR) reports that a long-term study showed that the very first welfare program, the Mother's Pension Program, had positive effects on children. The program seemed to help make it possible for beneficiaries to stick with education longer and earn more as young adults, as well as increased their lifespan.

Reduce Crime

People in favor of welfare also point out that it can reduce crime rates by helping people avoid being in desperation, where they feel the need to do desperate things like steal, carjack, and more. As a result, welfare can also help protect the middle and upper classes from being crime victims.

Social Good

Overall, proponents of welfare are interested in preventing starvation, disease, and misery among the poorest segments of society. They believe the welfare system is an expression of the very best social good.

Arguments Against Welfare

Not everyone is in favor of welfare. Reasons often given for being in opposition to welfare include:

Too Much Taxation

The money for welfare comes from the people through taxation. Opponents of welfare do not like for the government to take their tax money and give it to someone else. Instead, some people who oppose welfare encourage concerned individuals to find well-run charities and support them, rather than giving that responsibility to the government.

Creation of Dependency

Opponents of welfare also feel that welfare programs create dependency and produce a life situation where it's better to receive welfare than to work. It is possible for welfare recipients find themselves in a "welfare trap" where if they work too much, they will lose benefits that they cannot afford to replace.

Too Expensive to Maintain

Many critics are concerned that welfare is growing too quickly. They feel that the growth of welfare programs will bankrupt the U.S. economy and that the programs that exist aren't reducing the causes of poverty. In their view, this is made worse by immigration issues, and the idea that illegal immigrants are taking advantage of welfare that shouldn't.


Critics of welfare are also very concerned about welfare fraud, noting that seven welfare programs make the Office of Management and Budget's (OMB) list of programs with improper payments over $750 million per year. Welfare fraud taxes an already stretched system even more.

Helping Those Who Don't Deserve It

Welfare opponents are also concerned about helping those who aren't truly needy, including those who make poor choices and suffer from alcohol and drug addiction. They feel that Americans who can work should do so and that only the truly poor and disabled should receive assistance.

Moving Forward

Both proponents and opponents of welfare have good points. It's important to have a way for those in need to get help, without creating dependency or a "welfare trap."

The Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act of 1996 is a "welfare reform" law that requires states to ensure that welfare recipients are looking for work. The law also includes comprehensive child support enforcement and gives financial incentives for families to move from welfare into the workforce. In many cases, welfare assistance is now time-limited as well.

It's critical to have proper oversight of welfare programs while helping children get the best start possible in life. What's hard to know, of course, is how to meet these goals. Continuing to understand and discuss arguments on both sides is the first step toward truly solving the problem of Americans in need.

The Pro's And Con's Of Government Welfare Programs

     For a long time now, since the accomplished formation of a stable
government, the U.S government has had programs and passed laws that either
dealt with issues of or influence family. Many of these “family” programs and
laws currently in place today are frequently and commonly debated. One of the
most debated and most labored over “family” programs or law is Welfare. The
argument is whether or not to, and how welfare should be cut or minimized.

     The debate is simple enough, but the argument on welfare's benefits and
drawbacks is not. On the pro side of the argument, on which I stand, welfare
aids poor families as well as the economy and may help to reduce crime.
Welfare's benefits far out weigh its drawbacks. Welfare generally helps poor
families survive in today's economy by providing a means for them to obtain food
while they search for a job. These families receive foodstamps, to purchase food,
and a small amount of dollars to aid with either rent or utilities. Because of
this income from welfare, crime is reduced. This is because there is now more
income so the poor no longer have the need to go out and commit crimes to
attain that income. Welfare also aids in improving the economy because the
children of these families can afford to go to school and have a chance to make
someone of themselves. Instead of enrolling in welfare themselves, in the future
these people will make contributions to the economy and will be tax paying

     On the contrary, welfare is currently a great government expense that
tax payers pay for. Federal tax rates throughout the country are extremely high
and welfare, along with Medicare and Medicaid, are main contributors. The

Loading: Checking Spelling


Read more

Presidential Styles: Pro's & Con's of Personable Presidents and how it affects their leadership of America

721 words - 3 pages Just as every person has his or her own style about them, each president has had a different way of managing the executive office. Each president has certain values and beliefs which are reflected in the style that is chosen to manage the institution of the presidency. Presidential management focuses in on the decision making process and the process used to achieve an appropriate permanent solution. The process of decision making has become...

Genetically Modified Plants; Should Their Use Be Continued or Not? The Pro's and Con's.

1238 words - 5 pages For many years, the genetic makeup of flora and fauna organisms has been modified by humans. This is done through the cross breeding of two selected creatures that both have a set of desirable traits, to result in progeny that have an above average combination of the desired characteristics. Selective breeding methods can be very time consuming and more than often, aren’t very accurate. Over the past few decades, genetic scientists have...

"Cloning - A Gift From God ... Or an Injustice Towards Humanity?" A moral and religious debate between the pro's and con's of cloning.

1722 words - 7 pages Cloning - a Gift From God, or an Injustice Towards Humanity?In a world that is as fast paced as the one we live in today, it is hard to stop and remember the moral values and religious beliefs we were taught as children. We live in a world where science is put on a pedestal, and religion is a far off thought saved for holidays that we hardly remember the meanings of. Why is it that when we hear about scientific advancements we get...

The U.S. Government and Welfare

2350 words - 9 pages For a long time now, since the accomplished formation of a stable government, the U.S government has had programs and passed laws that either dealt with issues of or influence family. Many of these "family" programs and laws currently in place today are frequently and commonly debated. One of the most debated and most labored over "family" programs or law is Welfare. The...

Pros and Cons of Welfare Programs

1639 words - 7 pages AP Language and Composition The welfare system arose in the United States during the Great Depression, by the Social Security Act in the 1930s, providing medical and monetary aid to minorities such as women and their children, the elderly and later, entire families. During the Great Depression the Welfare system helped many families survive. Like many of the relief programs that were put into effect Welfare became a reform program, and...

Morality and Social Welfare Programs

1078 words - 4 pages The morality of social welfare systems, or the morality of crafting laws to aid American citizens in poverty, is a subject that (like myriad ethical issues) is hotly debated to say the least. For example, some opponents of social welfare institutions maintain the view that such programs "increase the reward or reduce the penalties" of poverty; thereby ostensibly making an impoverished state appealing even to people who might initially have been...

The Labour Government as The Creator Of The Welfare State

1502 words - 6 pages The Labour Government as The Creator Of The Welfare State A Welfare State is a system in which the government undertakes responsibility for the well being of its population, through unemployment insurance, old age pensions and other social security measures. In order to achieve this the Labour Government of 1945-51 introduced a number of reforms, including the National Insurance Act of 1946 and the Education Act. They...

The Welfare State and Government Responses to Economic Openness

1692 words - 7 pages The Welfare State and Government Responses to Economic Openness I. Introduction Economic openness is the phenomenon in which individual economies from all over the world become increasingly connected and interdependent through greater liberalization of trade and the vast movement of goods, services, and capital across borders. With the rise of globalization, positive effects have resulted from economic openness. The widespread benefits of...

Persuasive/Controversial Essay: TANF and SNAP welfare programs are a detriment to the U.S.

1825 words - 7 pages Lesak 1Amber LesakMr. GaugAP Government 313 May 2013Welfare "Benefits" UnemployedTemporary Assistance for Needy FamiliesWelfare began as a federally funded program in the 1930s during the Great Depression for mainly the elderly and disabled, but also the unemployed. Many Americans...

Government Programs During the Great Depression

1175 words - 5 pages With Herbert Hoover in office at the time of the crash of 1929, he believed it was not the government’s responsibility to get involved in helping the millions of Americans affected by this national crisis. However with elections coming up, Americans believed in a time for change. Franklin D. Roosevelt saw a chance to help save the American people and bring this nation of suffering back to a once thriving, prospering nation. With his election...

Investing in the future: welfare programs, includes a personal experience

1031 words - 4 pages Welfare and school reform are two of the most widely discussed issues in politics today. Many people are calling for reduction or elimination welfare programs as well as programs that provide breakfast and lunch at schools. They argue that people should be able to provide for themselves and their children with minimal government assistance, and spending other people's tax dollars to assist the less fortunate only makes the problem worse. The...

0 thoughts on “Welfare Pros And Cons Essay On School

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *